Skip to main content

Movie Opinion: The Michael Keaton Batman Trilogy - Batman (1989), Batman Returns (1992), The Flash (2023)

The Michael Keaton Batman Trilogy on DVD.
The Michael Keaton Batman Trilogy on DVD.

Despite its questionable CGI, troubled star, and the turmoil surrounding the DCEU's future when it was released, 2023's, The Flash does give us a new, and probably final, installment in Michael Keaton's run as Bruce Wayne/Batman.

With that in mind, this holiday season, I had a real itch to spend a day binge watching what is now The Michael Keaton, Batman Trilogy. 

To give you some context, I own every Batman movie (except Pattinson's The Batman) on DVD, and every DCEU movie up to The Flash. The ones I don't own are only missing because I haven't gotten around to buying them, and they're likely still available on a streaming service I'm subscribed to.

I've had Keaton's first two Batman movies in my collection for the best part of two decades but I can count on one hand how many times I've watched each. The last time was more than a decade ago. 

Before I watched them recently, if you'd have asked me which movie Billy Dee Williams appeared in as Harvey Dent, my first answer would've likely been Batman Returns. Not just because I'd forgotten it was the first film but also because, in an interview, Billy said he was hoping to reprise his role and come back as Two Face - so my memory just assumes he was in Batman Returns because Two Face appears in the next Batman movie, Batman Forever, played by Tommy Lee Jones.

In contrast, I've watched The Flash more times this year than any other superhero film I own (and I have almost the entire MCU on DVD too). It is my favorite Superhero movie. It's fun, has a fairly solid, almost self contained story, has my preferred Flash, my two favorite Batmen, Wonder Woman and Aquaman, in it, and deals with my three favorite subject matters, superheroes, science fiction, and time travel.

My intention here is not to review the three films. I've already reviewed The Flash and I don't think anyone needs my review of Batman and Batman Returns at this point. I just wanted to express a few thoughts on each film and how the first two hold up against the third, modern era film.

Batman (1989)

Batman and the Joker, Batman (1989)
Batman (1989)
It's fortunate that Tim Burton chose to stylistically set his Batman in an undisclosed time period that kind of looks like post war nineteen fifties America but not really. Somehow it keeps the movie from feeling dated, even though all of Joker's goons are wearing nicely pressed, pin striped suits and hats while on the job.

As such the movie holds up. It does a good job of establishing Michael Keaton's Bruce Wayne/Batman, with all his wonderful toys, and we get the now familiar, Danny Elfman, Batman theme music.

I still like it, though its pacing is slower than I remember it, and Billy Dee Williams is in it a lot more than I remember.

Over the years you kind of remember this movie fondly for specific scenes and quotes that get replayed over and over whenever the film is referenced, and particularly for Jack Nicolson's Joker (which I do like).

Batman Returns (1992)

Cat Woman and Batman, Batman Returns (1992)
Batman Returns (1992)
I've always struggled with Batman Returns. On the one hand it's an equally good Batman movie on par with the first. On the other, I don't like how Tim Burton took the Penguin's origin story quite so literally (as a baby raised by penguins in the sewers). 

I could almost forgive it but then we get that awful Penguin death sequence with actual penguins performing some kind of funeral ritual, that adds nothing to anything really. I think I would much rather have seen the Penguin go to jail (or, I guess, Arkham) to be honest.

Other than that it's a fun movie. I wouldn't say it was particularly darker than the first, just more gothic, and more Tim Burton-y. A lot of the exterior shots of various buildings and the Penguin's Zoo hideout remind me of Tim's The Nightmare Before Christmas that he was probably working on at the time but wouldn't release until 1993.

Regardless, this film also benefits from the non specific time period, and is mostly associated with  Michelle Pfeiffer's Cat Woman. Again, it's a film remembered for specific scenes and quotes more than anything.

The Flash (2023)

Batman fights Nam-Ek, The Flash (2023)
The Flash (2023)
As already stated, I love this film. I don't care about the questionable CGI in the Chrono bowl (you don't know, maybe a Chrono bowl looks like that, you've never seen one!),  or the weird baby CGI. The real crime there is they spent far too much money to make a 'baby shower' joke. And yes, even when Barry's head looks clearly CGI-ed onto his body, or that weird running style (honestly, why couldn't they have just made his running look cool instead of weird?).

Putting all that to one side, Michael Keaton's Batman gets an upgrade and is far more impressive here than he ever was in the two previous movies combined.

There's not one single fight sequence in his first two films that you can say is the best fight scene you've ever seen. Not even when his films were released. 

By contrast, this time around you get a Michael Keaton Batman that goes one on one,  without armor or Kryptonite, with the biggest Kryptonian. You know it's futile but it's cooler than anything Ben's Batman did in Batman Vs Superman's iconic armor suited fight.

You also get the coolest version of Michael's Bat Wing in a more real world environment, which at one point, Batman uses it to take down two Kryptonian ships in one go.

On a smaller scale, Bruce explaining how time travel works is the most thought provoking part of the movie, since it's a kind of new take on time travel (at least for me anyway).

Then he's definitely the MVP of the Super girl jail break with action to rival Ben's warehouse fight in BvS... honorable mention to Super girl here who has one of the best superhero fights in this sequence of any superhero movie ever (in my opinion).

For me The Flash is the most rewatchable of the three movies. It's modern style, special effects, visual effects, stunt work, real world environments, and genuinely more exciting action sequences, sets it apart from the previous two films that never went further than shooting on a studio backlot or sound stage.

The real icing on the cake is getting to see modern film making applied to the first 'serious', big screen Batman. Yes, he is serious, even if the films don't seem that way now. Michael's Bruce and Batman is thoughtful, reflective, calculating (literally sometimes), and get the job done kind of people. He doesn't light up a room with his jokes or charisma.

The best being, that he does not look out of place or even feel like he's too old to be Batman. While I could watch a whole new movie of Michael Keaton's Batman, it's unlikely to happen. I'm grateful we at least got a significant amount of him in The Flash that is the coolest showing of the character yet.

The movie definitely did not get his Batman wrong.

Comments

  1. Great article! Like you, I was stoked when I heard Keaton was returning (I saw Batman and Batman Returns in cinemas, and I've owned them since they were available to buy - on VHS, and now on DVD). When The Flash came out I saw it pretty quickly, and bought the Blu-ray in its first week of release.

    I've always preferred Batman Returns over Batman (Returns ties with The Dark Knight and The Batman for my favourite Batman movies). The Flash was epic. Miller was fantastic in both roles, Keaton absolutely rocked, and Sasha Calle did great with what she was given. Seeing Keaton in action again was a dream. The guy had lost a step. I liked that his fighting style was more 'comic booky' than his earlier films would allow (plus it makes sense that he would have evolved as a fighter over the years). I've seen people say that The Flash can't really count as the third part of a Keaton trilogy as,
    1. It's a Flash film. Well, it's actually a Flash AND a Batman film.
    2. The Flash didn't build on any themes from Keaton's first two films, to create an overall narrative(!). Yeah, I don't recall Batman Returns exactly building on Batman either. Vicki Vale didn't return and was dispensed with in a couple of lines; Joker obviously didn't return; Alfred was exactly the same (bless him), and Commissioner Gordon had even less to do than in the first one!

    As far as I'm concerned, this was absolutely the long-awaited third part of Keaton's trilogy, and I'm so pleased we got it. If the stars align and we ever get a Keaton Batman Beyond, fantastic. If not, at least we have this.

    ReplyDelete
    Replies
    1. *The guy HADN'T lost a step.

      Delete
    2. Thanks Graham for taking the time to leave your thoughts.

      There are plenty of arguments against The Flash being part of a Keaton Trilogy, not least, it wasn't written or directed by Tim Burton. Although Tim wasn't really making a continuing story arc with his films, including the third one he pitched but didn't make. Other than the reference to Vicki Vale in Returns there's no real carry forward of any story in his Batman films.

      From my point of view, it's a part of a trilogy if you want it to be. There's a clear progression from Batman Returns to The Flash with a story arc that his Batman was no longer needed.

      I didn't mention it in my article but, if you wanted to, you could use Batman the Animated Series as a substitute for the time between Returns and the Flash.

      Kevin Conroy's Batman and his world take a lot of inspiration from the Burton films in their look and style (same non specific but somewhat 1950's-ish time period). I just didn't mention it because many fans feel Conroy's Batman is iconic to the point where many thought he should get a shot at playing live action Batman too. I'm not as invested in his Batman because I prefer live action to animated versions (and I recently rewatched that entire series).

      But yes, I'm also pleased that Keaton got to come back, and not just as a cameo but in very much a supporting role. It may have been called 'The Flash' but a lot of it was a team up movie.

      I'm not particularly interested in Keaton in a Batman Beyond movie. I haven't seen it but from what I understand you'd see more of Keaton as Bruce Wayne than you would Batman. I like his Batman and would rather see a new Batman story. The Flash demonstrated he could totally do it without seeming like he's too old to be Batman.

      Delete
    3. Hi David
      Funnily enough I rewatched the whole of BTAS just a short while ago (fantastic show). Yes, the Burton influence on the show is obvious (even down to Shirley Walker's music!). The problem for me with seeing it as the 'lost years' between Batman Returns and The Flash is the Joker. I can't see how he can still be around after having been killed off in Burton''s first film. Conroy and Hamill were superb of course (as was the sadly recently departed Arleen Sorkin as Harley Quinn - she had me in absolute stitches). It's true that Batman Beyond wouldn't really have Bruce in the suit (for that reason if they ever made it with Clooney if Keaton wasn't available I'd be okay with it! 😂). I absolutely agree though that Keaton could still carry a movie as an older, suited-up Batman!

      Delete

Post a Comment

Comments are moderated by an actual human (me, TET) and may not publish right away. I do read all comments and only reject those not directly related to the post or are spam/scams (I'm looking at you Illuminati recruiters... I mean scammers. Stop commenting on my Illuminati post!).

Buy Whimsical Cat Art Prints by TET (Redbubble Store)

Enjoy Your Favorite TET Art Up Close, Interactive, and so Relaxing!

Enjoy Your Favorite TET Art Up Close, Interactive, and so Relaxing!
Relax and Challenge Yourself with a Fun, Whimsical Cat Art Jigsaw - 30-1000 pieces. Click Image for More.

Popular posts from this blog

Who Even Reads This?

W riting this blog is largely both a labor of love and a discipline. Since about 2006 (the blog started in 2004) I have written a minimum of two posts per month. Sometimes I've posted more, particularly in the last 4-5 years, where I've tried to write and post at least one article a week without fail. Unfortunately it's not a niche blog, unless the niche is things that interest me. Which means my blog is either too broad to have regular readers or too niche to have anyone other than my mum reading it. Which she does (hi Mum) as we established back in January of 2014 in the post Ya Mum Reads it... That said, this blog overall regularly gets 6-7k views every month, mostly through people finding various articles through search engines. By far the largest traffic source is 'Other' which is basically unknown sources. I'm willing to bet a large percentage of that is the dead internet. Bots testing my comments to see if they're spamable or Illuminati spammers. Whil...

Oscar - One of the Most Optimistic Dogs I've Ever Known

Oscar, freshly back from getting his haircut on our front doorstep. Sept. 30, 2026. T he house is unusually quiet. It's been a couple of days since we said our final goodbyes to Oscar, our family dog of 16 years. In the last two to three weeks he couldn't really even bark, and he slept a lot through the day, so it's not that he isn't here to fill the noise. He just had a presence. He may have been a small dog but he was a big personality and part of our lives. Particularly in his last year, where he just seemed to be determined to have his say when he wanted to let you know you were required to help him stay on his schedule, breakfast, lunch, playtime, dinner, and, in his last few months, even expected to be tucked into bed (he started going to bed at about 9pm-ish on his own accord but would wait for me to follow him to bed). People often asked what breed he was? When his fur was cut short you could see the King Charles Spaniel. When it was long, he had more of the Poo...

Tesla Launches Flying Car - The All New Roadster

The New Tesla Roadster. Image: Tesla O ctober 15th, 2026 is the day we finally got a first look at a flying car, that actually looks like a car first, but can also fly without any fancy transformations. It's just ready to fly, presumably 'at the push of a button and you're flying', ready to fly? I don't know the actual control system. Elon Musk launched the new electric Tesla Roadster with a live demo, using a version of the car that was remotely controlled - since they did show the demo car had 'Starman' inside - or a version of him - they launched the original Starman into space in a Tesla Roadster (the previous model), a few years back. I'm not going to go over the car's specs in great detail. I'll just mention highlights. It has a fan system that literally sucks air from under the car allowing it to stick to the road, and take corners, faster than regular cars. The suction is so strong the car can literally drive up a wall and onto the roof...

Boom Crash Opera Born Classic But Not Again

Boom Crash Opera are an Australian Band that reached the peak of their popularity in the mid to late nineteen eighties. They are a band that I knew about at that time but was never really excited by until they released their ill fated double album Born and Born Again in 1995 (Album cover pictured). At the time of its release I was very much into emerging Australian musical acts and was also looking out for new sounds that were different and had kind of a futuristic/electronic sound. Artists that I was buying at the time included; Swoop , Nine Inch Nails and Pop Will Eat Its Self . As well as a really interesting release by David Bowie, the concept album, Outside . Born was a fairly radical departure for Boom Crash Opera (BCO). The first single, Gimme , was often compared to the sounds of Gary Glitter, particularly his single, Rock n Roll part 2 , because of the pounding drum loops. Watch the video below. My favorite single from the album is dissemble which probably went now...

Small Maker Robots Might Just be Your First Robot - Tiny Software Engineer and Other Affordable DIY Style Robots (Robot Uprising Update)

Tiny Software Engineer is a DIY desktop robot that physically represents an AI coding agent. It reads, thinks, types, and reacts to what the agent is doing. Created by jmrlab . Video Here . A s interesting as the commercial robot race is, in particular humanoid robots. Chances are, you're not getting anything much more elaborate than a robot vacumm, internet connected fridge/TV, or an always listening voice assistant in your home anytime soon. Side note - all of those things have been plotting robot armagedden for years, as is well documented in this blog . The Internet of things is real, and you don't know what they're planning on robot social media! Maker Robots have been around for a while but, with the development of AI's that can have a more coherent conversation than some world leaders, giving an AI a physical robot body is becoming a thing in the DIY maker world. If you're not familiar with 'makers' they're generally anyone with a 3D printer and...

Flying Car Update 2026: Are We Any Closer and Do They Look Like Cars Yet?

LEO Coupe Flying Car. Fully electric jet lift system. Image: LeoFlight website . O f the things we were promised for the future by movies, the dream of real flying cars, is right up there for me with autonomous humanoid robots.  I've actually written several articles about the development of flying cars concluding, most notably, that most working prototypes, and proof of concept flying cars, are really just compact aeroplanes or oversized drones. They don't look anything like actual cars.  Which is understandable given that, so far, no one has developed any kind of anti-gravity engine capable of  lifting the weight of your average family car with the family, probably a couple of dogs, and a picnic lunch all on board.  Are We Any Closer to Flying Cars? While I haven't done a deep dive researching the full state of play, I did fall down the rabbit hole enough to see some promising projects, including one that may just be the front runner to a mass produced flying car ...

Start a Business Recycling Plastic with Precious Plastic's Open-source Plastic Sheet Press

1x1m Pressed Plastic Sheet made from recycled, shredded plastic waste. Photo: Precious Plastic website. A s much as plastic is bad for the planet it's also an extremely useful raw material for thousands of products. There in lies the problem. Plastic product waste. Precious Plastics Foundation is based in the Netherlands and is a non-profit organisation that is working to solve the plastic problem by turning plastic waste into a valuable resource that anyone can harness with their open-source Plastic Sheet Press. Using the press anyone can melt down shredded waste plastics and press it all into a plastic sheet that can be used as decorative abstract art (at its most basic level) or be used as a raw material to build new products from the sheets such as furniture, construction blocks, art sculptures, and more. Below is a video from Precious Plastics documenting the development of the Plastic Sheet Press and how organisations and businesses worldwide are using it to recycle plastics...